Why so many top execs miss the mark communicating in crisis

I was recently asked to comment on the fallout from the Air Canada CEO’s comments after a collision between one of its regional jets and a fire truck at LaGuardia Airport. Two pilots were killed and 41 others injured. Initial indications are the accident wasn’t the pilots’ fault. Yet CEO Michael Rousseau lost his job.
What went wrong? Rousseau delivered his condolences only in English. Air Canada is headquartered in Quebec, Canada is officially bilingual, and one of the deceased pilots was a French-speaking Quebec resident. He appeared not to care enough to express condolences in French as well. I have no evidence he was anything less than sincere, but in a crisis, “appeared” is often all that matters.
Leading in a crisis requires operating on three levels at once: emotional, psychological, and cognitive.
Emotional: dealing with your own feelings and understanding how everyone else, colleagues, customers, the public, is feeling. Empathy and trust are the currency here.
Psychological: how the incident shifts people’s risk-reward calculation. Does what you say make people feel safer working with or patronizing your organization, or less so?
Cognitive: the facts, the operational response. Does the crisis team deploy quickly, with the resources and training they need?
If you had to guess where CEOs typically over-index, it’s cognitive. They’re smart, hard-working, and well-versed in their businesses. Where they fall short is emotional. CEOs are rewarded for being analytical and hard-nosed. How they make people feel gets far less consideration, sometimes it’s even seen as a liability.
But humans are emotional beings first. Emotional response outpaces cognitive reasoning because, evolutionarily, it had to. Get the emotional level wrong, and the rest doesn’t matter.
The classic case is Johnson & Johnson’s response to the 1982 Tylenol poisonings. CEO James Burke recalled more than $100 million of product nationwide and told people not to take Tylenol. Shareholders bore the cost. But he correctly bet that reframing J&J as a “safety first” company would pay off over time, and it required action, not just words, to prove the company meant it.
So the next time a CEO asks what to do in a crisis, stop them. Have them consider how they want people to feel first. The right course of action follows from there.
Want the rest of the story? I’m now writing longer pieces on Substack. It’s all free, so check it out here.
